For all my economist friends out there. After reading the second half of an article by Dudley Seers published in 1963, titled "The Limitations of the Special Case", I'm oh-so-very glad that I never studied any economics! Despite my own status as a
U.S. Conspiracy (more on that some other day!) I pity you fools!
Since undergraduate teaching does not do much, if anything, to break down parochialism and to bring home the realities of the modern economic world, the recruit to graduate school easily falls into the trap of admiring technique for its own sake. If the content is dull, the student turns to form, and this is indeed encouraged. Far from becoming more practical (as say, medical teaching does in its later stages), economics becomes still more abstract.
--Dudley Seers
Graduate students of economics are confronted with a vast array of concepts, techniques, and detailed theoretical constructions. They perforce live in a strange world of indifference maps, kinked demand curves, cross elasticity, marginal propensity to consume, liquidity preference, nt national product, sampling error, linear programming, and input-output matrices. They spend much of their time gaining familiarity with specialized concepts and techniques, an dtheir success as graduate students is gauged largely by the degree to which they master them.
--H.R. Bowen
6 comments:
You want me to have a go at you don't you? I'll resist the urge to connect ALL the dots for you, but chew on this for a little:
a) Why would anyone with an iota of an independent brain swallow down someone else's generalities without question?
b) If you were to remove specific terms, I see nothing damning in Bowen's piece at all. In fact, even as it is, only the last sentence seems wrong.
If I was back home, rest assured you would have been physically hurt by now...
thanks man... you are a true friend... now im even more unsure about my major... my parents are going to keel me!
ali: somehow i knew you'd be the first to comment on this post! how predictably brainwashed you are, my child, into a defense of the Dark Arts against all assaults! these are just excerpts from the article. i was too dead in the morning to pick out all the juicy ones so i posted just the first that i found by Seers. find the article and read it if you find the time. it's an interesting read except for the fact that all Seers is saying is that ecomies of developed and underdeveloped countries are different BECAUSE they are different!!! funny it was!
and if it's any consolation, i have a more damning piece coming up about social science majors being a US conspiracy!
Dude, the point is, koi subject sahi tarha parhay baghair diss na kar! Especially when I've already commited to five more years in it!!!!
dude you're just ticked off coz you've decided to devote your life to the pursuit of something which is fundamentally flawed in its approach to begin with. you're life isn't worth squat!
im bound by my degree to say: "excuse me but just cause u suck at it doesnt mean u can take it out on the subject, pick on something ur own major!!"
However...i totally agree with the dudes. someone needs to liven up the subject a bit!
Post a Comment